I have been a student of genealogy since I was sixteen years old. Over the years, I have traced my documented family history back to 1044. DNA testing has taken the story even further, pointing toward a connection with ancient people whose remains were discovered in the Lichtenstein Cave near Osterode in Lower Saxony, Germany.
The Lichtenstein Cave should not be confused with the country of Liechtenstein. This cave is an archaeological site in Germany where the remains of a Bronze Age family clan were discovered.
Archaeologists originally identified the remains of forty people—nineteen males and twenty-one females. Later investigations indicated that the cave may have contained the remains of as many as seventy-five individuals. These people lived approximately 3,000 years ago.
Because the DNA was unusually well preserved, researchers were able to identify relationships among members of an extended family spanning several generations. The evidence suggests that the cave was a family burial chamber rather than the site of a massacre or human sacrifice.
My family’s journey appears to have led from Germany to France, then to England, and finally to America in 1640. I can truthfully say that my family has roots in Germany, France, England, and America.
However, let me ask a plain country-preacher question: What does that ancient German connection give me the right to do today?
Suppose the Truitts Returned to Germany
Suppose the Truitts, now a large family, decided to band together and return to the area around Osterode. Suppose we announced that our ancestors had lived there 3,000 years ago and that God had therefore given the land to us.
Would our DNA prove an ancient connection to the area? Perhaps.
Would that give us the right to claim somebody else’s farm, house, or village? No.
Would it give us the right to drive the present inhabitants from their homes? Absolutely not.
What if we said, “Our ancestors suffered greatly through the centuries, so we deserve a homeland of our own”?
Our suffering might deserve recognition, sympathy, and justice, but it still would not give us the right to inflict suffering upon innocent German families living there today.
DNA is not a deed. Ancient ancestry is not a modern property title. A historical connection to a place does not give anyone the moral right to remove the people presently living there.
My family returning to Germany after 3,000 years would not give us the right to claim what is not ours.
Yet this kind of reasoning lies at the heart of political Zionism in Palestine.
An Ancient Connection Does Not Erase the Present Population
The Jewish people undeniably have an ancient historical and religious connection to the land. That fact should not be denied. Jewish people have also suffered centuries of persecution, expulsions, pogroms, and the unspeakable horrors of the Holocaust.
Christians must condemn antisemitism wherever it appears. Hatred of Jewish people is sinful, just as hatred of Arabs or Muslims is sinful. Every person is created in the image of God and is a soul for whom Christ died.
But recognizing Jewish suffering does not require us to deny Palestinian suffering.
Palestinians had homes, farms, villages, churches, mosques, businesses, and family burial grounds in that land. They are not imaginary people who appeared from nowhere. They are human beings with families, memories, and roots of their own.
One people’s ancient connection cannot erase another people’s present existence.
“Divers weights, and divers measures, both of them are alike abomination to the LORD.”
—Proverbs 20:10, KJV
God does not have one standard of justice for the people we favor and another standard for those we dislike. If it would be wrong for the Truitts to drive German civilians from their homes, it is also wrong for Palestinians to be driven from theirs.
Justice must have an honest weight and an honest measure.
What About God’s Promise to Abraham?
Many Christians believe the modern State of Israel has an unconditional right to the land because God made promises to Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob.
God certainly made a covenant with Abraham. We cannot tear those promises out of the Bible. But neither can we tear them away from Christ and turn them into a modern real-estate deed.
The Apostle Paul explained where the promise finds its fulfillment:
“Now to Abraham and his seed were the promises made. He saith not, And to seeds, as of many; but as of one, And to thy seed, which is Christ.”
—Galatians 3:16, KJV
Paul then declared:
“And if ye be Christ’s, then are ye Abraham’s seed, and heirs according to the promise.”
—Galatians 3:29, KJV
The New Testament does not teach that salvation or membership in God’s covenant family comes through DNA. It comes through Jesus Christ.
“For they are not all Israel, which are of Israel.”
—Romans 9:6, KJV
God’s kingdom is not built upon ethnicity, military power, national borders, or earthly governments. Jesus told Pilate:
“My kingdom is not of this world: if my kingdom were of this world, then would my servants fight.”
—John 18:36, KJV
That ought to settle something in the Christian heart. Our calling is not to help an earthly government conquer territory. Our calling is to preach Christ, seek justice, show mercy, and love our neighbors—even our enemies.
The Bible Never Gives Permission to Commit Injustice
Even under the Old Covenant, possession of the land was never presented as permission to practice oppression. The prophets repeatedly warned Israel that religious claims would not protect a nation that abandoned justice.
“Woe unto them that decree unrighteous decrees, and that write grievousness which they have prescribed;
“To turn aside the needy from judgment, and to take away the right from the poor of my people.”
—Isaiah 10:1–2, KJV
God also commanded Israel concerning the stranger:
“But the stranger that dwelleth with you shall be unto you as one born among you, and thou shalt love him as thyself.”
—Leviticus 19:34, KJV
If our interpretation of prophecy permits us to ignore the cries of suffering children, something is wrong with our interpretation.
If our theology requires us to excuse the destruction of homes, the displacement of families, collective punishment, starvation, or the killing of civilians, something is wrong with our theology.
The God of Abraham is also the Judge of all the earth.
“Shall not the Judge of all the earth do right?”
—Genesis 18:25, KJV
God’s righteousness does not change according to the flag flying over a government building.
Political Zionism Is Not the Gospel
We must distinguish between Jewish people and political Zionism. They are not the same thing. Not every Jewish person supports the policies of the Israeli government, and criticism of a government is not hatred of an ethnic or religious people.
Likewise, opposing the killing of Palestinians does not mean approving Hamas, terrorism, or the killing of Israeli civilians. Murder does not become righteous because we sympathize with the murderer’s cause.
I do not support the killing of Jewish civilians. I do not support the killing of Palestinian civilians. I do not support terrorism, collective punishment, forced displacement, or revenge.
My concern is not which side can produce the oldest map. My concern is what is just before God.
“He hath shewed thee, O man, what is good; and what doth the LORD require of thee, but to do justly, and to love mercy, and to walk humbly with thy God?”
—Micah 6:8, KJV
Political Zionism is a political ideology. It is not the gospel of Jesus Christ. The modern State of Israel is a government. It is not the Church, and its political leaders are not above moral judgment.
No government should be permitted to wrap itself in Bible prophecy and then demand that Christians remain silent about injustice.
My German Roots Give Me a Connection, Not Ownership
I can appreciate my ancient connection to Germany. I can study the history, visit the region, honor my ancestors, and acknowledge the path by which my family eventually reached America.
But I cannot knock on a German family’s door and say, “My ancestors were here first, so this house now belongs to me.”
I cannot point to my DNA results and demand that they leave.
I cannot appeal to events from 3,000 years ago as justification for taking away their rights today.
I may have a connection to the land, but I do not own it.
The same moral principle must apply to everyone. Ancient Jewish ancestry may establish a profound historical connection to Palestine, but that connection cannot, by itself, grant a modern government the right to take another person’s home or drive civilians from the land.
The Bible says:
“Thou shalt not steal.”
—Exodus 20:15, KJV
That commandment does not contain a political exception.
We Must Carry the Burden for Every Soul
I pray for Jewish people. I pray for Palestinians. I pray for Muslims, Christians, Israelis, and Arabs. Every bomb that falls lands upon souls for whom Christ died.
The Church should not be cheering for war. We should be carrying a burden for the lost.
Our enemies are not targets to be destroyed; they are souls who need to be saved. Our commission is not to conquer Jerusalem with weapons. It is to take the gospel of Jesus Christ into all the world.
I believe we can acknowledge the Jewish people’s ancient connection to the land without endorsing the dispossession of Palestinians. We can condemn antisemitism while also condemning injustice committed by the Israeli government. We can mourn murdered Israelis while also mourning murdered Palestinians.
That is not compromise. That is applying one moral standard to every human life.
DNA is not a deed.
An ancient promise is not a license to steal.
Scripture is not a weapon to be used against suffering civilians.
And no claim to land—whether based upon ancestry, history, politics, or religion—can cancel the command of Almighty God:
“Therefore all things whatsoever ye would that men should do to you, do ye even so to them.”
—Matthew 7:12, KJV
If I would not want someone to take my home, destroy my church, drive away my family, or kill my grandchildren, then I must not defend those things when they happen to someone else.
That is not politics.
That is the Golden Rule.